|
|
|
Jeffrey McDaniel
anatomy of a poem: Joanna FuhrmanThis is an interview I conducted several years ago with Joanna Fuhrman via e-mail about her poem “In the Basement of the Museum of Potential Urges", which appears in her book Ugh, Ugh Ocean (Hanging Loose Press). The poem appears below, followed by specific questions about the poem. In the Basement of the Museum of Potential Urges Who cares if there are more "exciting" exhibitions ** Jeffrey McDaniel: What inspired this poem? Was there an initial blast of language, a phrase? Or did it begin with an idea?
JF: Actually part of the title came from a fortune cookie, I can’t remember exactly…something like “You have many potential urges.” I thought the idea of a “potential urge” was funny. Isn’t an “urge” the opposite of something is “potential.” For awhile I was trying to stick the phrase in every poem, most of which were too abstract and awful. (Months later my friend’s girlfriend found the same fortune in a cookie in Tucson, 2000 miles away.) But anyway, to answer your question, the poem was always about the basement of the museum. I supposed that seemed to be the place in the building where one would put the most shameful exhibits. People usually hide what they don’t want others to see in the basement, no. But I think the poem started with the image of a bathroom that I suppose could have been anywhere. Though actually, hmm have you ever been to the bathroom in the basement of p.s. 1? There has been a really disgusting (in a good sense) installation there for a long time with organ-like sculptures and strange noises, but I don’t think it was there when I wrote the poem, but it would fit perfectly in the poem. So yeah, the basement might also be quieter, darker and less visted than the rest of the building.
JF: Yeah, I was aware that this poem required more of a driving rhythm than some of the other poems in the book. I think I am always pretty conscious about sound, but I think the beat of this poem is maybe different than my other poems—more foregrounded. There is something about the music of this poem that reminds me of Richard Hugo, particularly “Degrees of Gray in Phillipsburg” which starts “You might come here Sunday on a whim. Say your life broke down.” I think I associate that poem, and Hugo in general, with my own adolescence. It’s kind of ironic I guess because so many of his poems are about feeling old, but I think there is something kind of adolescent about enjoying one’s own self-pity. So yeah, at one point working on this poem I imagined it as kind of a rewriting of Hugo’s poem, in music and tone. Of course, now looking at it the form and music of the poems are very different from his, which I can’t account for. I would have liked it better if my poem had more formal verve and a sense of development, but I didn’t want to overwrite it. I guess I sacrificed the feeling of a kind of fullness for density. The images are all kind of emblematic so I don’t think I could really have to many of them without undercutting each one. It’s always a little frustrating for me when I have a kind of abstract formal vision in my head for a poem and the poem just refuses to take the form I want it to. I really wanted to have even stanzas with even lines for this poem, but it just didn’t work for me that way. It’s not that I am not capable of writing in a stricter meter or whatever, but I am never willing to sacrifice other values for the meter. Plus I mean now I think some of the form’s awkwardness may work pretty well with the content.
JF: I am not really sure how many drafts it went through because I didn’t keep them. Though, I remember it being a lot, even for me. I make lots of changes on the computer and I only kept two other drafts so it is hard to say. I do know that just about every line in this poem changed…also I remember a few lines being changed back and forth.
JF: No, actually the first draft had a completely different ending. “I’d like to meet you by the marble stairs/That foot on special at the high priced// cafeteria would fit better between both of our mouths.” Those are some pretty lousy lines, huh. I don’t think they lasted for long in the poem, but I did save this draft on my computer. Anyway, I think you are right in guessing that the star image came later in the process, but I can’t remember when or where. I also realized later, a few months after writing the poem, that there is a Jean Valentine poem that compares nipples to stars (not drool-wet though.) I worry that I might have stolen the metaphor though actually the words in my poem are pretty different than in hers and it is maybe not the most original image to start with. (But I mean I love Jean Valentine’s poems, but that particular image isn’t anything in itself.)
JF: This is interesting to me. I think I wanted the “you” in most of the poem to be both myself and my boyfriend, (but really more him than me). In early drafts, the story about the cafeteria was in first person. There was a clearer differentiation between the “I” and the “you” throughout the poem (even though the speaker was really more of my boyfriend there than myself), but anyway those early drafts seemed kind of clunky. But I wonder if your questions suggests a larger issue, I mean I think “yous” in poems are always in someway about the poet (and also, I guess the unknown unseen universal reader). I have a section poem for my friends called “Admonitions” based somewhat on Jack Spicer’s series, and yeah, in that poem it might be clearer, than in “In the Basement,” who the “you” is in each section (because each part is titled with the friend’s name and many of the poems include details about my friends). Yet, I wonder if this supposed clarity is misleading. I mean I am basically giving advice to my friends in those poems, but I am just as much giving advice to myself. I think it was Ed Foster who said in his essay on Spicer’s Admonitions that the difference between Frank O’Hara and Jack Spicer was that the “you” in Spicer was more universal than in O’Hara. There’s a sense in Spicer that when he addresses his friends he is talking to them, but also talking to the phantom person behind them. In a letter in the Admonitions, Spicer uses the image of a hall of mirrors. “The frightening hall of mirrors is universal beyond each particular reflection.” I like this metaphor in relation to “In the Basement” also. The speaker is addressing her lover, but since her address is mediated by language’s “hall of mirrors” her reflection is also there. I don’t know. I’m wondering why you assumed the “you” referred to the speaker when you were first reading the poem.
JF: I'm not exactly sure. I knew when I started the poem, I wanted to write the most uncomfortable and embarrassing poem that I could. (Recently at the John Wieners Tribute at the Poetry Project Anslem Berrigan said that whenever he gets writers block he remembers that Wieners had said that he just tries to write the most embarrassing thing he can think of. Later that evening some speaker, I can't remember who, came up and said the John Wieners was misquoted, and that he actually said, "I just write the dumbest thing I can think of," but whatever. For me-- writing this poem-- embarrassing seems to be a good motivation.) I think what makes the image so humiliating is that the speaker is trying so hard-too hard really. She's not just showing off her breasts, she's trying to make them something which they are not. I think without "drool" as an adjective the image would still make me uncomfortable. It's a much more "poetic" kind of image than what I usually write-cheesy, really. I've actually always hated that really famous Andre Breton poem, ('My woman' blah blah blah) but I suppose you could say the end of this poem of mine is kind of a reversal of that impulse to objectivity the other through metaphor (Imagine if Petrach's Laura was writing about herself?) The speaker tries, quite consciously, to poetize herself, to turn herself through sheer will into the object of desire. (Actually, I just remembered that Hugo poem I mentioned also ends with an image of the waitress objectified through figurative language. Her red hair "lightening the wall" becomes the mode of release from "The Degrees of Gray." His poem ends "the girl who serves you food/is slender and her red hair lights the wall" "-so maybe my ending also goes back to my rewriting of his poem too. For what it's worth) But anyway, as I was saying, the image in my poem is over-the-top: the nipples aren't just stars, (which is kind of a ridiculous thing to say about oneself to start) but they are "drool wet." Instead of seeming beautiful and sexy--which the speaker might to be attempting through the image--she appears to be a parody of sexuality. But on the other hand, I don't think the image is totally unsexy either. I think there is something attractive about feeling "wrong," awkward, and uncomfortable, whatever you want to call it. It's sort of the opposite of the Hollywood version of the erotic. As I wrote in another poem, I'm a great believer in the "inherent glamour of error." Comments |
CONTRIBUTING WRITERS
Christian BökStephen Burt Daisy Fried Rigoberto González Major Jackson Reginald Shepherd A.E. Stallings STAFF WRITERS
Michael MarcinkowskiEd Park Fred Sasaki Don Share Elizabeth Stigler Nick Twemlow Emily Warn PREVIOUS WRITERS
Kwame DawesKenneth Goldsmith Jeffrey McDaniel Ange Mlinko Patricia Smith Rachel Zucker RECENT COMMENTS
Evidence, But of What?, a Mini-Essay on Form (6)more scots, less porn (8) The Anatomy of Pleasure (16) Happy Birthday, George Gordon, Lord Byron (4) The Nude Formalism (6) RECENT POSTS
Evidence, But of What?, a Mini-Essay on Form (Daisy Fried)Illness and Poetry (Reginald Shepherd) The Bride-Choosing (Daisy Fried) Good Night, Sweet Ladies: A Thought About Slightness (Daisy Fried) The Anatomy of Pleasure (Daisy Fried) CATEGORY ARCHIVE
Poetry magazineAWP Arts Awards Biography Books Criticism Distribution Education Film Music Obituaries Outrageous Photographs Poems Poetry Out Loud Poetry and the Internet Politics Readings TV poetryfoundation.org AUTHOR ARCHIVES
Christian BökStephen Burt Kwame Dawes Daisy Fried Kenneth Goldsmith Rigoberto González Major Jackson Jeffrey McDaniel Ange Mlinko Ed Park Fred Sasaki Reginald Shepherd Patricia Smith A.E. Stallings Nick Twemlow Emily Warn Rachel Zucker Subscribe to the RSS feed. ![]() What is RSS? |
