Poetry Foundation
Poetry Magazine
January 2009
Poems by C.K. Williams, Kim Addonizio, Anne Winters; previously unpublished Langston Hughes, introduced by Arnold Rampersad; Michael Hofmann on Bishop and Lowell. More
Harriet

Forrest Gander
Poets in New York, 5 of 6

Olds%2C%20One%20Secret.jpg

Because Sharon Olds has been publishing for forty years and because her work has drawn so much attention, both disparaging and laudatory, most people I know already have decided attitudes towards her work.

One Secret Thing
, her new cycle of family poems (Knopf, 2008) includes some intensely moving poems such as the one printed below, “To See My Mother.” Here, deftly orchestrated line breaks and clausal contractions, along with Olds’ characteristically concatenary metaphors, achieve transformative force. The psychological dimensions of the phrase “since I had met her” and the repetitions and variations pierce me on each rereading.

To See My Mother

It was like witnessing the earth being formed,
to see my mother die, like seeing
the dry lands be separated
from the oceans, and all the mists bear up
on one side, and all the solids
be borne down, on the other, until
the body was all there, all bronze and
petrified redwood opal, and the soul all
gone. If she hadn’t looked so exalted, so
beast-exalted and refreshed and suddenly
hopeful, more than hopeful—beyond
hope, relieved—if she had not been suffering so
much, since I had met her, I do not
know how I would have stood it, without
fighting someone, though no one was there
to fight, death was not there except
as her, my task was to hold her tiny
crown in one cupped hand, and her near
birdbone shoulder. Lakes, clouds,
nests. Winds, stems, tongues.
Embryo, zygote, blastocele, atom,
my mother’s dying was like an end
of life on earth, some end of water
and moisture salt and sweet, and vapor,
till only that still, ocher moon
shone, in the room, mouth open, no song.

10.14.08 | Comments (7)



Comments


It's interesting to hear an Olds' poem described as having "deft" line breaks... But I do agree that when Olds hits a note, as she did for me most explicitly in the Gold Cell (and in those last lines above), the note resonates long and deep, and certainly raises the ante on what we are willing to see and reveal.

Posted by: Lemon Hound on October 14, 2008 10:36 PM

Thank you for making a post about Sharon's new book. I agree her work is beautiful and moving, and it's been essential poetry for me for a long time. I'm glad to see a blog on Harriet about her.

Posted by: Larry Kaplun on October 15, 2008 12:46 AM

Sina--
re: Olds' line breaks. I agree it's unusual to talk about Olds' line-breaks as deft, but I think they are deft in a sense, not that they are clickingly discreet entities inside a larger entity, or that they make stunning enjambments or interruptions, or display great wit, but because they do exactly the work they need to in an Olds poem, which is to stay somewhat out of the way of the poem's intense *about-ness*, to make themselves a non-issue, except when they spotlight certain end-words like, as in the poem above, "to see my mother die, like seeing" which makes the mother's death and seeing itself somewhat equivalent...
among others.
Daisy

Posted by: Daisy on October 15, 2008 9:31 AM

daisy's "deft" is right, to my mind . . .

I think Olds is a great poet, and her "Selected Poems" a few
years back should have won all the awards . . .

part of what makes her great is her craft—

her skills are handtooled unique—

"they do exactly the work they need to"

as daisy insightfully phrases it . . .

what works for her is what she worked for,

the Olds flow,

the Olds enjambement, the pauses and clauses, the

effective use of internal rhymes and

all—her technique is to envy for.

...

Posted by: bill knott on October 15, 2008 10:46 AM

Daisy,
I agree, yes, it's not about the line breaks with Olds. It seems so old fashioned to even think about line breaks these days, but they still excite me.

Posted by: Lemon Hound on October 15, 2008 2:56 PM

>they still excite me

Me too.
D.

Posted by: Daisy on October 15, 2008 6:25 PM

I'm behind an Olds book or two. I enjoy her work, although it often makes me roll my eyes. She is a poet of excess, which is honorable, I think.

"To See My Mother" is lush, wild, presumptuous, flagrant, and touching, like a talented drag artist who shows you the poignancy of being human, the impossibility of merely two genders, Olds here birthing and deathing with a similar exuberance.

Olds can be campy in a bad way, too. Really amazingly bad. But I think the "amazing" is the key. Even her bad poems have a delicious outrageousness to them. They don't cross their knees demurely under calf-length skirts.

Posted by: Glenn Ingersoll on November 8, 2008 5:55 PM

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Your name and a valid e-mail address are required. Thanks for waiting.)



CONTRIBUTING WRITERS
Wanda Coleman
Olena Kalytiak Davis
Forrest Gander
Lavinia Greenlaw
Cathy Park Hong
Javier Huerta
Travis Nichols

STAFF WRITERS
Michael Marcinkowski
Fred Sasaki
Don Share
Elizabeth Stigler
Nick Twemlow
Emily Warn

PREVIOUS WRITERS
Christian Bök
Stephen Burt
Kwame Dawes
Linh Dinh
Daisy Fried
Alan Gilbert
Kenneth Goldsmith
Rigoberto González
Major Jackson
Ada Limón
Jeffrey McDaniel
Ange Mlinko
Mark Nowak
Lucia Perillo
D.A. Powell
Reginald Shepherd
Patricia Smith
A.E. Stallings
Rachel Zucker

RECENT COMMENTS
Bolaño Blitz (20)
DURA (5)
Against Poets (1)
ALASKARNALITY (5)
Editing yourself out... and in. (5)

RECENT POSTS
Australia: Don't Look Away (Forrest Gander)
DURA (Cathy Park Hong)
Against Poets (Javier Huerta)
Terroir, Code Orange (Linh Dinh)
Bolaño Blitz (Travis Nichols)

CATEGORY ARCHIVE
Poetry magazine
AV
AWP
Arts
Awards
Biography
Books
Criticism
Distribution
Education
Film
International
Language
Music
News
Obituaries
Outrageous
Photographs
Poems
Poetry Out Loud
Poetry and the Internet
Politics
Readings
Science
TV
Translation
poetryfoundation.org

AUTHOR ARCHIVES
Christian Bök
Stephen Burt
Wanda Coleman
Olena Kalytiak Davis
Kwame Dawes
Linh Dinh
Daisy Fried
Forrest Gander
Alan Gilbert
Kenneth Goldsmith
Rigoberto González
Lavinia Greenlaw
Cathy Park Hong
Javier Huerta
Major Jackson
Ada Limón
Jeffrey McDaniel
Ange Mlinko
Travis Nichols
Mark Nowak
Ed Park
Lucia Perillo
D.A. Powell
Fred Sasaki
Don Share
Reginald Shepherd
Patricia Smith
A.E. Stallings
Elizabeth Stigler
Nick Twemlow
Emily Warn
Rachel Zucker

Subscribe to the RSS feed.
What is RSS?

Poetry Tool






OR SEARCH
Events
Art Beyond Borders
Eamon Grennan




Fullerton Hall
Art Institute of Chicago
111 South Michigan Avenue
Thursday, January 15
Free admission

More

Email Sign Up
Sign up for updates from the Poetry Foundation. Click here to learn more, or enter your email address to sign up!