|
|
|||||
Kenneth Goldsmith's writing has been called some of the most "exhaustive and beautiful collage work yet produced in poetry" by Publishers Weekly. Goldsmith is the author of eight books of poetry, founding editor of the online archive UbuWeb (http://ubu.com), and the editor I'll Be Your Mirror: The Selected Andy Warhol Interviews, which is the basis for an opera, Trans-Warhol, premiering in Geneva in March of 2007. Goldsmith is also the host of a weekly radio show on New York City's WFMU. He teaches writing at The University of Pennsylvania, where he is a senior editor of PennSound, a online poetry archive. More about Goldsmith can be found on his author's page at the University of Buffalo's Electronic Poetry Center: http://epc.buffalo.edu/authors/goldsmith.Kenneth Goldsmith
Conceptual Poetry Conference: Audio and VideoVideo and audio recordings of the University of Arizona Poetry Center symposium Audio Caroline Bergvall
Kenneth Goldsmith
Conceptual Poetics: On Appropriation
A question I'm often asked is, how is conceptual poetry's embrace of appropriation anything new when, after all, poets have been appropriating from time eternal. They claim that, particularly in the twentieth century, with the advent of collage and pastiche, it's all been done before. And then there's always the mention of Kathy Acker, who was a brilliant collagist, but less an appropriator. I find myself answering that, yes, while collage and pastiche are commonplace, actual appropriation is rare to non-existent in literary history. What is the difference between collage / pastiche and appropriation? When a poet collages a non-aleatory work together, one selects choice fragments to construct a meta whole, often predicated upon the taste -- and whim -- of the poet, ripe with intention. Even types of writing that worked hard to eschew conventional textual construction, such as certain strains of Language Poetry, out for prioritized, highly specified textual fragments placed on a page next to each other for the ultimate "zing." Kenneth Goldsmith
Conceptual Poetics: Christian Bök
Christian Bök "Two Dots Over a Vowel" Christian Bök began by discussing a group of poets around UbuWeb (Caroline Bergvall, Craig Dworkin, Robert Fitterman, Kenneth Goldsmith, Simon Morris, Darren Wershler-Henry, and himself) to "disavow the lyrical mandate of self-conscious self-assertion in order to explore the readymade potential of uncreative literature." Bök claims that they resort to a diverse variety of anti-expressive, anti-discursive strategies (including the use of forced rules, random words, copied texts, boring ideas, and even cyborg tools), doing so in order to erase any artistic evidence of 'lyric style.' He cited the precedents for the group as being Perec, Warhol, Cage and Bruce Andrews and claimed the group to be inspired by movements such as Oulipo, American conceptual art of the 1960s. Bök next showed an image of Steve McCaffery's "William Tell: A Novel," which is simply a lower case "i" with a colon atop of it instead of a dot. He recalled the story of William Tell and then conflated it with the William Tell episode of William S. Burroughs, where he shot his wife dead playing William Tell. Bök examined the linguistic implications of "the mark," in terms of self-expression, in relation to a target, as well as a graphic manner of mark making. And then he further extended these metaphors to examine the tension between literatures "will" and how much a work of literature "tells." Kenneth Goldsmith
Conceptual Poetics: Kenneth Goldsmith
Kenneth Goldsmith "Conceptual Poetics" I presented the journal on Conceptual Poetics that I did here for the Poetry Foundation last year. In brief, Conceptual writing or uncreative writing is a poetics of the moment, fusing the avant-garde impulses of the last century with the technologies of the present, one that proposes an expanded field for 21st century poetry. Conceptual writing's concerns are generally two-pronged, as manifested in the tensions between materiality and concept. Conceptual writing obstinately makes no claims on originality. On the contrary, it employs intentionally self and ego effacing tactics using uncreativity, unoriginality, illegibility, appropriation, plagiarism, fraud, theft, and falsification as its precepts; information management, word processing, databasing, and extreme process as its methodologies; and boredom, valuelessness, and nutritionlessness as its ethos. Language as junk, language as detritus. Nutritionless language, meaningless language, unloved language, entartete sprache, everyday speech, illegibility, unreadability, machinistic repetition. Obsessive archiving & cataloging, the debased language of media & advertising; language more concerned with quantity than quality. In their self-reflexive use of appropriated language, conceptual writers embrace the inherent and inherited politics of the borrowed words: far be it from conceptual writers to morally or politically dictate words that aren't theirs. The choice or machine that makes the poem sets the political agenda in motion, which is often times morally or politically reprehensible to the author. With the rise of appropriation-based literary practices, the familiar or quotidian is made unfamiliar or strange when left semantically intact. No need to blast apart syntax. Conceptual writing is more interested in a thinkership rather than a readership. Readability is the last thing on this poetry's mind. Conceptual writing is good only when the idea is good; often, the idea is much more interesting than the resultant texts. Kenneth Goldsmith
Conceptual Poetics: An Editorial Pause
On a recent radio interview, Language poet Bruce Andrews talked about how, back in the early 70s, using a paper cutter radically changed his work, breaking up his writing into a modular process. It was the correct response for the time. Today, we have immense information moving capabilities at our fingertips and new movements like Conceptual Writing or Flarf are the correct responses for our time. If writing is not taking these new conditions into its poetics, it simply cannot be considered contemporary. If nothing else, what the Conceptual Poetry and Its Others conference did was codify this tendency for the record. The other significant notion that emerged from the conference was that conceptual poetics is a many-headed monster, showing itself wildly adaptable to a wide variety of interests and agendas, the baseline of the practices being floated by technology. In a sense, what the conference did was to bring the field of poetics up to date and in line with other art forms and long-established cultural trends. Words like "sampling," "appropriation," "cut-and-paste," "mixing" and "remixing" were in constant use as were frequent references to technology, globalization and multi-lingualism. The papers and discussions were very much focused on the concept of poetry off the page, bleeding into galleries, performances, sound installation, on the airwaves, interventionist strategies, websites and blogs, all of these not being the traditional spaces where poetry happens. Yet all the poets got up and "read," and all have published numerous books. Conceptual poetry is a poetry that, in fact, knows no bounds; in this, its wildly contemporary. As respondent Brian Reed put it, "Genres don't evolve, they get more confused over time." Reed claimed that the poet is now a post-production studio, enabling new notions of collaboration fueled by distributed agencies and sites of production. Kenneth Goldsmith
Conceptual Poetics: Cole Swensen
Cole Swensen "What to Do Besides Describe it: Ekphrasis that Ignores the Subject" Cole Swensen began by stating: "In attempting to get beyond the 'emotions recollected in tranquility' paradigm, which is what it seems to me conceptual poetry in its widest sense is trying to do, I've been increasingly drawn to models of poetry as revealing something about the way we think and even expanding our perspectives or patterns of thought." She then introduced the concept of ekphrasis and the theories of Semir Zeki, a scientist who argued that the visual arts, particularly painting, train us to see constants and to gradually develop overall perceptual constancy. Swensen wondered what the implications and parallels in poetry might be. She commented that in the visual fields, the ways in which we're asked to see and to "read" haven't changed all that much, based as they are on a primary figure/ground relationship. What has changed, she argues, is subject matter. Swensen argues that "Increasingly, the visual arts and some poetry have worked to distill subject matter so that core structural elements and their dynamics are laid bare or at least made much more apparent. but it seems that the visual arts have been more successful at this than poetry, and in part, it's because, after a very promising start, epitomized by Gertrude Stein, who recognized that there was something to be gained in translating cubism's geometric and perspectival shifts into writing, poetry took a turn which confused distillation with simplification, turning precisely away from that which would expose underlying dynamics apparent through rhythm, echo, juxtaposition, etc. and toward simpler language, where 'simpler' was understood to be both 'clearer' and 'truer,'" with the result being poetic language dominated by subject matter, by information. Swensen posited that ekphrasis as a tool can help poetry by historically analyzing how the visual arts have accomplished this. She concluded with a lengthy participatory group discussion looking a numerous works of modernist visual art to show how a unifying principle between very different subjects could be seen as similar. She asked the audience to "think about how, in each case, subject matter has been modified, compromised, distilled in order to let the dynamics become a little more apparent." Kenneth Goldsmith
Conceptual Poetics: Tracie Morris
Tracie Morris "Black conceptual poetics: examples for crafting" Tracie Morris states that "I hope that, by bringing the sonic, political and creative sensibilities, we can, as embracers of experimentation and variety, assert this as a critical component of American conceptual poetics through found art, uncreative writing, transgressions through otherness as well as conventional writing practice and utterance." Morris examined how Black poetics undermines notions of typification based on the initially non-human status of Black standing in the Americas, in particular, by means of creativity in Black speech as code. Black code is continuously constructed and assimilated through American identity, it is at once a fixed and fluid medium. Morris noted that one way this is negotiated in African American contexts is through the humorization of Black misery. Morris then discussed the Ring Shout as being both multidisciplinary and "performative." Shouting performances incorporate dance (the ring shout), singing and music in a quasi-ritual context, using grammatical codification as codes for survival. She claims that "There are two issues being presented here. One of African linguistic traits interfacing with the everyday language of Standard American English, the other of encoded meaning within the speech that has an entirely different significance... Gatherings by the enslaved were codified so in many instances." A more focused discussion of language ensued with the 1980s occurrences of "Yo" and "mira" that were practically synonyms in the coagulated lingua franca of Brooklyn streets. Morris discussed how language Caribbeanisms from English-speaking nations and other cultural elements from the French Caribbean also became part of the mainstream African American landscape. What followed was a look at musical artists who emphasized the relationship between uttered sound and music as performative utterance. This flow in Hip Hop is conveyed through the artists' use of assonance, consonance, internal rhyme, speed, shifting of metrical stresses and creative uses of language. Examples were provided by Rakim and Missy Elliott. Morris summed up her talk by commenting that the intersection of African American poetic presentations in the context of popular song was compelled by a coded survival strategy and is now an established aesthetic. Kenneth Goldsmith
Conceptual Poetics: Caroline Bergvall
Caroline Bergvall "Social Engagement of Writing" Caroline Bergvall spoke about several recent projects that correspond to the questions of bilingual awareness and conceptual structure. Her main points touched upon question of multiple languages: where and how does one write when one has not one language of origin, but several? What is the site of such practices, the site multiple forms and spaces of inscription? Bringing poetry through a combination of modes and histories. Some from visual arts, some literary, some sonic. Body representation as a space. Exploring the authored body, giving it signs, finding its signals. Verbal and libidinal. Restrictions and actions of social readings of bodily space on what one calls one's own body. Body as marker of an extended authorial space: performances/sitework/soundwork. Space itself becomes a field of work, a local/e, precise with its own histories. She discussed her multi-national -- and hence multi-linguistic -- background as a problematic situation of self-definition as an artist and how sending bios & summaries for shows and readings for her is a complex affair; the social and cultural difficulties in calling oneself a poet in the first place. Bergvall said, "I am inclined to consider conceptualism not primarily along strict critical lines but rather in the open-ended, integrative and often conflicted and socially engaged approaches that have also defined conceptual arts practices... A conceptual writer or conceptual poet so defined has a stake in arts practice, as much as they have one in poetics. Or perhaps one could simply say, they have a stake in broader cultural practice, one in which verbal and non verbal inscriptive methods coexist and are coextensive." She concluded by showing extensive documentation of her sound and visual works which illustrated the above notions of the multi-lingual, mishearing, translation, and identity. Kenneth Goldsmith
Conceptual Poetics: Craig Dworkin
Craig Dworkin "The Politics of Conceptual Writing" Dworkin's premise is that formal techniques (such as appropriation, citation, or the filtering of databases, or any of the procedures that might define 'uncreative' or 'conceptual' practices) always necessarily signify, but they do so in contingent, contextual, historicizable ways (rather than in fixed a priori ways). He asks, how and in what ways can we assess such techniques? Dworkin cited a Language poet who bragged about the daring of his pirated literary appropriations but then across the bottom of every page in big block letters -- and without apparent irony -- was a warning stating that it was forbidden to quote from the essay without permission. Dworkin went on to discuss the unchecked ventriloquism of George W. Bush's speeches, which are self-plagiarizing and formulaic. Dworkin states that, when Bush recycles the words of his speechwriters and handlers, it's unremarkable, but when a poet does the same thing, it's a distinctive statement, and an alignment without or against certain poetic protocols and ethoi. Kenneth Goldsmith
Sentences on Conceptual Writing
Poet's quotes compiled by Frances Sjoberg on the occasion of the Conceptual Poetry and Its Others Conference, University of Arizona
1. In poetry, they talk about finding your voice, which is too often a way of evading the voices to be found in the writing. 2. Not only do I consider works of official verse culture to be poetry (which is not, for me, an honorific category), but also one of the key features of official verse culture [is] that it could necessarily include some poetry that I like quite a lot. 3. I prefer minerals to insects but I have been working on this with my ontologist. 4. As an alternative to National Poetry Month, I propose that we have an International Anti-Poetry Month. As part of the activities, all verse in public places will be covered over--from the Statue of Liberty to the friezes on many of our government buildings...Parents will be asked not to read Mother Goose...Religious institutions will have to forego reading verse passages from the liturgy...with hymns strictly banned...No vocal music will be played on the radio or sung in concert halls. Children will have to stop playing all slapping and counting and singing games and stick to board games and football. 5. Oddly, it is a form of dissent these days to hold out that art that doesn't get the market share can actually be as valuable as the art that does....I'm for the ketchup that loses the race. 6. Attention: Write down everything you hear for one hour. 7. There is still a great deal of conceptualizing that leads up to any intuition.
1. Conceptual frameworks always determine the scope and form of my poems. Particularly the improvised ones. 2. We often associate medical advances as helping the body, but here I want to emphasize the structural or conceptual dystopia of sexism that impacts the structure of the female body. 3. We will be looking at...the performative utterances of Black women poetically and in some cases, musically. The interpretation...gives us insight into how different vocal modes, sounds and tones are understood by the listener and reader. 4. Philly! If I ate cheesesteak I'd be in heaven but as it is, I'll be happy to be back east with the hard core language school posse as they beat me into submission before I join the club! 5. The text is the body. The body tests text. 6. Racial and sexual power dynamics have not changed for 500 years, Morris says, and she doens't expect a change for 500 more. 7. The requirements are consistent attendance and promptness (this is mandatory. No late papers will be accepted and no incompletes are offered for this class.
Kenneth Goldsmith
Charles Bernstein Recants
TUCSON, May 31 — Charles Bernstein, best known as the co-editor of the influential 1970s journal L=A=N=G=U=A=G=E and a prime proponent of the poetry movement by same name publicly renounced many of the positions that he had abided by over the past three decades. Bernstein, who has a volume of Selected Poems forthcoming from a major New York trade publisher, appeared before a crowd of several hundred at the Conceptual Poetry conference at the University of Arizona Thursday afternoon and admitted his mistakes in the form of a lengthy poem, "Recantorium (a bachelor machine, after Duchamp after Kafka)." Mr. Bernstein backed away from his negative opinion of what he has termed "official verse culture," saying that these poets do, in fact, "represent the best and the finest, the most profound and significant, the richest and most rewarding, poetry of our nation." Mr. Bernstein, who once held the opinion that only elitist and obscure poetry should be praised, now claims that "only poets working in solitude and individually can produce poems of enduring value" and has embraced "a poetry without limits of time or place, a poetry universal address and true to the timeless human spirit." In addition, he now advocates that "clearly written expository prose, with a delineated argument including a beginning, middle, and end, is the only guarantor of Rational Mind." Kenneth Goldsmith
Marjorie Perloff's Unoriginal Genius
Marjorie Perloff's keynote for the Conceptual Poetry Conference in Tucson set forth a clear agenda: making a distinction between the poetics of thirty years ago and now: Language Poetry vs. Conceptual Poetry. She claimed that the poetics of, for example, Ron Silliman's anthology In the American Tree -- with its play on William Carlos Williams's Modernist classic In the American Grain -- is being superceded by the new transnational and global culture of the internet. Perloff went on to ask how has the digital dissemination of new poetry and poetics -- whether in journals, or on sites such as Ubuweb, Pennsound, Ron Silliman's blog or here on Harriet -- affected the writing of poetry itself? She also questioned the values of a poetics based on identity in a time when neither phone numbers nor email addresses tell us where caller and recipient are actually located, nor does an email address provide vital statistics about its possessor; when an AOL or Yahoo address, for example, reveals neither nationality, ethnicity, race, religion, age -- and often not even gender. We are moving away, she claimed, from a geographical, from identity politics to shifting identities and communities, all this being reflected in the new poetry. She gave numerous examples of Language Poetry, which she termed the "period style of the 1980s": a poetry of programmatic non-referentiality, words and phrases refusing to "add up" to any sort of coherent, much less transparent statement. The defeat of reader expectation -- a kind of cognitive dissonance-- is central to these poems. Kenneth Goldsmith
Concptual Poetry Conference ScheduleConceptual Poetry and Its Others Thursday, May 29 4 p.m. Reading with Charles Bernstein and Tracie Morris 5 p.m. Break 7 p.m. Keynote Address with Marjorie Perloff
9 a.m. The Politics of Conceptual Writing, Craig Dworkin 10:15 a.m. Forms of Social Engagement, Caroline Bergvall 11:30 a.m. Uncreative Writing Workshop, Kenneth Goldsmith Kenneth Goldsmith
UbuWeb :: New Addtions, Spring 2008
Tellus Audio Cassettes (1983-1993) Kenneth Goldsmith
Designer Label PoetryDerek Melander "Nomad", 2007 (video) In the grand tradition of Nick Beef's DieKu" series or Claude Closky's Mon Catalogue, Derek Melander creates a poem out of the labels on the clothing in his closet. The resultant poem is: Dreams Divided The Natural Uniti Kenneth Goldsmith
UBUWEB :: Featured Resources January 2008
Selected by Alex Ross 1. Robert Ashley "She Was a Visitor" 2. Kurt Schwitters "Sonata in Urlauten" 4. The Films of Mauricio Kagel 5. Charles Amirkhanian "Dog of Stravinsky" 6. Bernd Alois Zimmermann "Musique pour le soupers de Roi Ubu" 7. Pauline Oliveros "Sound Patterns" 8. Ezra Pound "Sestina: Altaforte" 10. Robert Ashley "The Wolfman" Alex Ross has been the music critic of The New Yorker since 1996. His work has also appeared in The New Republic, The London Review of Books, Lingua Franca, and The Guardian. From 1992 to 1996 he was a critic at The New York Times. He has received two ASCAP-Deems Taylor Awards for music criticism, fellowships from the American Academy in Berlin and the Banff Centre, and a Letter of Distinction from the American Music Center for contributions to the field of contemporary music. He played keyboards in the noise band Miss Teen Schnauzer, which gave only one public performance, in 1991. His first book, "The Rest Is Noise: Listening to the Twentieth Century," a cultural history of music since 1900, was published in October 2007 by Farrar, Straus & Giroux. Kenneth Goldsmith
Henri Chopin (1922-2008)
Henri Chopin died yesterday (03/01/08), at home in England with his family, peacefully. Henri Chopin's sound poetry Henri Chopin, explorer of the body's voices (1922-2008). For the last forty years, with his sound poetry revue OU (1964-1974), then through his participation in various international sound poetry festivals, through his personal experience in the experimental studios of radio stations in Köln, Paris, Australia, Canada or Sweden and in his concert/performances throughout Europe, Henri Chopin has consistently and unceasingly opened the ways to unexplored spaces beyond all known languages. Thanks to the systematic use of microphones, amplifiers, tape recorders, editing and mixing consoles, he has given a voice to realms beyond modern or experimental music, beyond any note system and headed for spaces without norms, categories, definitions or limits: spaces of permanent metamorphosis. Read more... Kenneth Goldsmith
UbuWeb - New Additions : Late Fall 2007
All Avant-Garde All The Time - UbuWeb Podcast #2: Komar & Melamid "The People's Choice Music" (1997) Four Films by Gordon Matta-Clark: Audio Selections from The Sackner Archive: Kenneth Goldsmith
UBUWEB :: Featured Resources December 2007
UbuWeb Featured Resources: December 2007 1. The Films of Toshio Matsumoto (all, especially Weavers, Mothers, Ki, and Sway) 3. Marie Mencken "Glimpse of the Garden" (1957) 4. Peter Campus "Three Transitions" (1973) 5. Edgard Varêse and Le Corbusier "Poême électronique" (1958) 6. Kristin Oppenheim "Selected Audio Works 1994-1997" 8. Pandit Pran Nath "Ragas of Morning and Night" 9. I.B.M. 7090 - Music From Mathematics 10. "Tagasode" Edo period, 17th century 11. Hidatsa: Lean Wolf's Complaint 12. Penelope Umbrico (especially Arrhythmia (All The Dishes On Ebay) and Your Choice) Aeron Bergman and Alejandra Salinas are artists whose work meets aesthetics and politics. They currently live and work in Oslo where Bergman is head professor of the digital department at the Art Academy of Oslo, Norway, and special advisor to the Nordic Sound Art Master program, a joint program between the major Scandinavian art academies. The artist duo have done major installations at art centers such as Centre d´Arte Santa Monica in Barcelona, Taipei Fine Art Museum, ICC Tokyo and the Serralves Museum in Porto; and sound performances around the world such as the Palais de Tokyo in Paris, the Knitting Factory in New York, and the CCCB in Barcelona; as well as running the sound art publisher Lucky Kitchen. Kenneth Goldsmith
Repost: In Barry Bonds I See The Future of Poetry
In light of yesterday's indictment, I feel the need to repost this, first published here back in August, when Bonds was on the verge of his record. Rereading it, I feel even more strongly that Bonds embodies the future of poetry. Like it or not, it's staring us in the face. (Thanks to Al Filreis for the memory jolt).
Barry Bonds has become the embodiment of Posthuman: "the Bonds' milestone signifies an end to the humanist discourse. In the classic sense of Baudrillard's "The Precession of Simulacra," the idea of Barry Bonds has long preceded the actual event, hence predetermining the outcome. And the outcome is obvious. Barry Bonds is being crucified for the inevitable; he is a martyr for the future. And in the future, just as our children will reminisce about when humans beings still played baseball, we shall reminisce about the time when human beings still wrote poetry for other humans.
Kenneth Goldsmith
UBUWEB :: Featured Resources November 2007
UbuWeb - Featured Resources: November 2007 1. Brion Gysin "I Am" Machine-poem (1960) 2. Janet Zweig "Mind Over Matter" 3. Gregory Whitehead "Pressures of the Unspeakable" 5. Sam Taylor Wood, from "Stoppage" 6. François Dufrêne, "Tenu-tenu" Crirythme (1958) 7. John Giorno "I Don't Need It, I Don't Want It, and You Cheated Me Out of It" 8. Georgina Dobson & Cupboard Simon "The Message" 9. Louis-Ferdinand Céline "Television Interview" (1961) 10. Adrian Piper "Here and Now" Special Offsite Bonus: Kelly Mark "I Really Should" (Audio CD) Extra, offsite: Santiago Sierra "11 PEOPLE PAID TO LEARN A PHRASE"
Kenneth Goldsmith
UBUWEB :: Featured Resources October 2007
UbuWeb Featured Resources: 1. Guy Debord "In Girum Imus Nocte Et Consumimur Igni" 2. Guy Debord "Howlings Against Sade" 3. Yoko Ono "Snow Is Falling All The Time" 4. Tadanori Yokoo "Three Animation Films" 5. Susan Sontag "The Aesthetics of Silence" 6. Gertrude Stein "The Making of Americans" 8. Patrizia Vicinelli "Seven Poems" 10. Apollinaiire "Le pont Mirabeau" Special Offsite Bonus: Marc Lavoine "Le pont Mirabeau" UbuWeb: http://ubu.com Kenneth Goldsmith
UbuWeb Featured Resources Selected by Juliana Spahr and Wayne Koestenbaum
__ U B U W E B __ ------------------------------------------ Featured Resources: 1. Learn to Say Penis 2. Germaine Dulac "La coquille et le clergyman" 3. Maya Deren "Ritual in Transfigured" Kenneth Goldsmith
In Barry Bonds I See The Future of Poetry
The inevitability of Barry Bonds serves notice to all poets invested in the Humanist tradition: your tenure is doomed. Barry Bonds is not only the future of athletics, but he's also emblematic of the future of poetry. More machine than man, chemically enhanced, Bonds is our first mainstream Posthuman public figure. Moving awkwardly, robot-like, festooned with machines -- a barrage of cameras following his every move and enormous noise-canceling headphones to silence the jeers -- he's a media-made technologically-supplemented Frankenstein. We dismiss him a as fraud, but we know in our hearts that his way is the way of the future; regardless, we cheer his accomplishment. We disdain his Posthumanism, but we shall soon come to realize that we created the phenomenon of Barry Bonds. We demand our athletes to be super-human and super-human they shall be. Bonds just points to the fact that being human has ceased to be enough: we demand the precision and complexity of machines, in athletes, in politicians, in business and in the arts. And what we demand, we now have. Barry Bonds has become the embodiment of Posthuman: "the Bonds' milestone signifies an end to the humanist discourse. In the classic sense of Baudrillard's "The Precession of Simulacra," the idea of Barry Bonds has long preceded the actual event, hence predetermining the outcome. And the outcome is obvious. Barry Bonds is being crucified for the inevitable; he is a martyr for the future. And in the future, just as our children will reminisce about when humans beings still played baseball, we shall reminisce about the time when human beings still wrote poetry for other humans. Kenneth Goldsmith
Close Radio (1976-79)
Close Radio (1976-79) - MP3s & Audio Stream 111 audio works recorded for KPFK by visual and performance artists between 1976 and 1979. Includes rarities and never-before heard cuts from mostly LA / CalArts-based artists such as John Baldessari, The Kipper Kids, Martha Rosler, Jack Goldstein, Ant Farm, Hermann Nitsch, Paul McCarthy, Mike Kelley and many, many others. From the Evidence of Movement show at the Getty. Kenneth Goldsmith
The Xenotext Experiment: An Interview with Christian Bök
Christian Bök: Postmodern life has utterly recoded the avant-garde demand for radical newness. Innovation in art no longer differs from the kind of manufactured obsolescence that has come to justify advertisements for "improved" products; nevertheless, we have to find a new way to contribute by generating a "surprise" (a term that almost conforms to the cybernetic definition of "information"). The future of poetry may no longer reside in the standard lyricism of emotional anecdotes, but in other exploratory procedures, some of which may seem entirely unpoetic, because they work, not by expressing subjective thoughts, but by exploiting unthinking machines, by colonizing unfamiliar lexicons, or by simulating unliterary art forms. The Xenotext Experiment: An Interview with Christian Bök in Postmodern Culture | PDF Archive Kenneth Goldsmith
To Be (Un)Real![]() ![]() I recently gave a lecture recently to a group of poetry MFAs on uncreative writing, appropriation, information management and unoriginality. During the Q&A, a student declaimed, "C'mon, man, be real. Drop all that stuff and be real, you know, artist to artist." To which I responded, "If you can give me a definition of what real is then I can be real with you." I thought to myself, wow, writing is so far behind other art forms in this regard. Could you imagine after a lecture someone say to Jeff Koons, "Hey, Jeff, drop all that stuff and be real." Never. No one expects Jeff Koons to "be real." Jeff Koons has made a career out of being "unreal." Likewise, during a pop concert -- say, a Madonna concert -- it's hard to imagine someone shouting out to Madonna to be real. No one expects Madonna to really sing, rather they revel in the image of her while listening to a pre-recorded vocal track. Would the "real" Madonna please stand up? For the past two decades, "realness" has ceased to be an issue in music, art and fashion. But in writing we're still expected to "be real." Twenty five years after Baudrillard, these poetry students were still prioritizing Romantic notions of authenticity -- "truth", "individuality" and "honesty" -- over any other form of expression. My god! Is it a case of naivety, amnesia or just plain ignorance? Kenneth Goldsmith
The 365 Days Project, Part 2 (2007)
Kenneth Goldsmith
These People Have Contributed Materially in Many Ways to Make My Writing What it is. Please Do Not Hold it Against them.
Kenneth Goldsmith
I Am Unpacking My Digital Library. Yes, I am.
In answer to my own call for a pro-consumerist poetry, I was reminded that writers have long been the ultimate consumers. This has been true in analog times -- the relationship between library and writer is a paragon of consumerism -- and is even more pronounced in our digital environment. In navigating the enormous field of available textual material in our collective networked digital dispensaries, the craft of writing lies in the acquisition, collecting, organization and archiving of existing texts rather than in the creation of new ones. In doing so, our traditional relationship to textuality, where the struggle for meaning trumps all, is inverted; the acquisition of text becomes more valuable than the content of the acquired texts: quantity trumps quality. How I navigate -- rather than how I create -- is what distinguishes me from another writer. I am an intelligent agent carving a unique path through the this thicket of language; what distinguishes my practice from yours is the particular swath I carve. Kenneth Goldsmith
I Promise To Write Better PoetryAra Shirinyan "Resolution: I Promise to Write Better Poetry" [PDF, 5.2 mb] Kenneth Goldsmith
T=A=S=T=E
Ange, I'm going to not only agree with you, but trump you one and say that it's not only temperament which is a motivating force in the creation of art, but even more important is the notion of taste. Any avantist who made a point of killing art did it with impeccable taste, hence its ultimate absorption into the canon of art. Take Duchamp. Every objet trouvé of his reeked of his taste. What if, for example, Duchamp had chosen a light bulb (as Johns did later with impeccable taste) instead of a urinal? a shoe (as Warhol did later with impeccable taste) instead of a bicycle wheel? What made these anti-art objects essentially Duchampian was his great taste. In writing, Jackson Mac Low, too, had amazing taste: he made all the right choices to free himself of choice-making. Contrary to my own claims, I'm always banging my head against the realization that no matter how hard you try, you can never remove the individual from art. I have made arguments for ego-less art, found art, art driven by chance operations and many other strains, but in fact there's always someone behind the curtain, manning the machines. I have yet to encounter tasteless art. We try too hard, which is why I'm always in favor of doing less. If there's one thing that the avant-garde has shown us, it's that regardless of form, non-expression is impossible. Kenneth Goldsmith
UbuWeb Radio
UbuWeb Radio is up and running. Listen to a 24-hour continuous stream from UbuWeb's vast MP3 archives. All avant-garde, all the time. Kenneth Goldsmith
Writing's Crisis v.1.0
With the rise of the web, writing has met its photography. By that I mean, writing has encountered a situation similar to what happened to painting upon the invention of photography, a technology so much better at doing what the art form had been trying to do, that in order to survive, the field had to alter its course radically. If photography was striving for sharp focus, painting was forced to go soft, hence Impressionism. Faced with an unprecedented amount of digital available text, writing needs to redefine itself in order to adapt to the new environment of textual abundance. Kenneth Goldsmith
Book Cover RantSean Flannagan "Book Cover Rant" In the vein of DieKu, this time with book covers. Full series after the jump. Kenneth Goldsmith
"I dedicate this work to the U.S.A., that it become just another part of the world, no more, no less."
LECTURE ON THE WEATHER (1975) by John Cage COMMISSIONED BY THE CANADIAN BROADCASTING CORPORATION IN OBSERVANCE OF THE BICENTENNIAL OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA PREFACE The first thing I thought of doing in relation to this work was to find an anthology of American aspirational thought and subject it to chance operations. I thought the resultant complex would help to change our present intellectual climate. I called up Dover and asked whether they published such an anthology. They didn't. I called a part of Columbia University concerned with American history and asked about aspirational thought. They knew nothing about it. I called the information desk of the New York Public Library at 42nd Street. The man who answered said: "You may think I'm not serious, but I am; if you're interested in aspiration, go to the Children's Library on 52nd Street." I did. I found that anthologies for children are written by adults: they are what adults think are good for children. The thickest one was edited by Commager (Documents of American History). It is a collection of legal judgments, presidential reports, congressional speeches. I began to realize that what is called balance between the branches of our government is not balance at all: all the branches of our government are occupied by lawyers. Kenneth Goldsmith
4th of July Break
More from the woman who brought you Frozen Words. Here is her summer line, just in time for the Fourth of July. Lovely, no? More weedrobes here. See ya in a few days... Kenneth Goldsmith
Frozen Words
Stay cool this weekend. These words were made out of ice and set out in the landscape and left to melt. The largest project was the word VIEW which stands 6 feet high. The other words were done with marquee letters that are about 18 inches high. The high winds off Lake Ontario sometimes blew individual letters over before they had time to melt. View full Flickr set here Kenneth Goldsmith
ApologiesTo Our Latina/o Readers, First of all, my apologies that this piece offended you. It was not intended to. Rather, it was meant to bring some of the simmering comments up from below the fold. Also, it was meant to highlight the fact that the Spanish language was absent from this site, something I learned from all of you. And thirdly, it was meant really as a self-effacing comment regarding my -- and most American's -- sad fact that many only speak only one language. It obviously didn't fly and once again, I apologize. I use this chunk of text when I read in countries where English is not the first language. And I read the text in the native language of that country. I always make a fool of myself, which, as implied by the text is my intention. I stumble over words, mangle sentences. It gets to the point in most places where it is simply unintelligible, particularly in countries where the language is very different from English (Helsinki was a disaster!). The result is a cultural breaking of the ice, a debunkment of American linguistic Imperialistic tendencies -- most of which are almost never addressed in such situations (when was the last time an American poet apologized for speaking English in a foreign country before a reading? It never happens. Instead the reading takes place in English). I have read this piece in English in front of the entire MLA during this year's Presidential Forum. It's a great piece when spoken; now I see that the point is lost when written. The situation of non-understanding is something I use as a positive trope. I try to treat English in my work as a foreign language, hence the "utopian state we find ourselves in right now." Here is the way the paragraph reads normally for a reading: I am an American poet, and like most Americans, I speak only one language. When asked to read in Stockholm, I figured that the last thing Sweden (or the rest of the world) needed was more imported American culture--in English--no less (remember the Clash's "I'm So Bored With The U.S.A."?). Hence, I've decided to start my reading in Swedish, a language that I have never spoken nor written. Thank you for your understanding and again, please accept my apologies. -- Kenneth By the way, I love Rich's idea of retyping Neruda's Canto General! Kenneth Goldsmith
Soy un poeta estadounidense
Soy un poeta estadounidense, y como el resto de mis compatriotas, hablo sólo un idioma. Cuando me pidieron que escribiera para Harriet, el blog del Poetry Foundation, supuse que lo último que necesitaba Harriet (o para el caso el resto del mundo) era más sobre la cultura norteamericana (recuerdan la canción de The Clash "I'm So Bored with the U.S.A"?). Por lo tanto he decidido escribir este blog en español, idioma que nunca he escrito o hablado. Lo más probable es que nadie entienda una sola palabra de lo que digo, ni siquiera si el español es su primera lengua. Asà que estamos a mano: ambos estamos en la situación de no entendernos. Lo único que podemos hacer es escuchar cómo suenan las palabras en lugar de pensar en qué quieren decir. Y al hacerlo todos accedemos a una nueva relación con el lenguaje que nos permite volver a enmarcar lo mundano en el lenguaje de lo mundano. Por muchos años he estado trabajando en aras de una situación como ésta en la que nos encontramos ahora: una en la que el lenguaje sea sólamente formal y concreto. Como el lenguaje mismo, esta entrada en el blog a la vez tiene y no tiene sentido. Esta página está cargada de sonido que posa o aparenta ser lenguaje. PodrÃa continuar el resto de mis entradas en español, pero creo que han entendido el punto. Después de este tortuoso comienzo, pueden entender mejor lo que estoy tratando de hacer con mi trabajo: aproximarnos la situación utópica en la que nos encontramos ahora, una de buscada ignorancia. (Tr. Mónica de la Torre) Kenneth Goldsmith
The Avant-Garde. Priceless.This unbelievable full-page MasterCard ad ran in last Wednesday's NYTimes. Left to right: Jack Smith, (unidentified man), Harry Smith, Panna Grady, William S. Burroughs, Andy Warhol; NYC, winter 1964-65 Kenneth Goldsmith
School of Quietitude?A commenter on Silliman's blog asked the following question: "Just curious Ron, but are any of your SoQ [School of Quietitude] poets happy to be tagged with this label now, today? Does anyone refer to him/herself as SoQ? As I say, just curious." I'm curious too. Do any of the other bloggers or readers of Harriet identify themselves as such? Either way, how does Silliman's term strike you? Does such as school exist or is it a figment of Ron's imagination? Kenneth Goldsmith
DieKuWonderful 5-7-5 syllable haikus comprised of snapshots of tombstones called "DieKu", mysteriously appearing on the streets of New York recently. Enigmatically penned by "Nick Beef - NYC" DieKu #1
DieKu #2
Kenneth Goldsmith
Pro-Consumerist Poetry
The poetry world has yet to experience its version of Pop Art -- and Pop Art happened nearly 50 years ago. While the New York School fondled consumerism sweetly, using pop as a portal to subjectivity -- (O'Hara: "Having a Coke with you /is even more fun than going to San Sebastian, Irún, Hendaye, Biarritz, Bayonne") -- it never came close to the cold objectivity, naked, prophetic words of Warhol: "If you're the Queen of England you couldn't have a better Coke than the bum on the corner." Clearly, Frank O'Hara is not our Andy Warhol. However, all is not lost. In the two posts below are two contemporary poets dealing with consumerism head-on, in a way that would make Andy proud. Kenneth Goldsmith
Pro-Consumerist Poet #1
Nemerov constructed this poem by simply listing every brand she touched sequentially during a day, from the moment she woke up, until the moment she went to sleep: it's hard to imagine a more accurate contemporary self-portrait. And it doesn't get "sexier", "cooler", or "more accessible" than this.
Kenneth Goldsmith
Pro-Consumerist Poet #2
Using a tactic similar to Nemerov's, Mon Catalogue is a complete listing of every possession Closky owns, which he then transcribed into first-person singular possessive catalogue-speak. Again, it's an amazingly contemporary form of self-portraiture, defining oneself not only by what one owns, but described in the language of consumerism. Chilling and dead-on.
Le volume utile de mon réfrigérateur est bien supérieur aux capacités habituelles, et me permet de stocker mes produits frais et surgelés. Le compartiment a viande a temperature réglable et le bac a legumes avec contrôle d'humidité m'assurent une parfaite conservation de mes aliments. Outre le froid ventilé, il me fabrique et me distribue des glaçons ainsi que de l'eau fraIche. De plus, mon réfrigérateur est équipé d'une façade anti-salissure qui me facilite son entretien.
Pour matifier peu à peu l'aspect luisant de ma peau, resserrer mes pores dilatés et assainir mes comédons, j'ai une solution: nettoyer chaque soir mon visage avec mon gel purifiant au zinc associé à un actif régulateur de sébum qui élimine, sans me décaper, les impuretés accumulées pendant la journée. Ma peau ne brille plus. Le pouvoir apaisant du zinc, renforcé par un agent hydratant, adoucit et ressource les zones sèches de mon visage. Ma peau ne tire plus. Kenneth Goldsmith
Continuous Texts
The piece is related to Charles Bernstein's poems that he made by transcribing word for word the correction tape on his Selectric typewriter. Both pieces have overt social and political overtones in this time of increased government spying and corporate snooping. Here's Wakeling's description: "As we type and edit our attention jumps from paragraph to paragraph and from program to program, leaving a trail of disconnected phrases and commands. Much of what we type is deleted before the final draft is reached, but it has not necessarily disappeared. The subject of sic is the record kept by a keylogger installed on my computer. Since the the keylogger records every key pressed, the data contain information best kept private, but the range of information is so great and cluttered with such noise it remains impenetrable and pretty much meaningless. Like a blog, sic is frequent and chronological--but unlike a blog it is a strictly linear record of non-linear processes. From a step back, the many colored key-commands and black phrases of text illustrate an abstract and personal topography of thoughts and actions. The illusion of sic is that everything is displayed, but the reality is that without the final products of the labor to compare, the record will always be incomplete, and will remain pieces whose sum is less than the sum of the whole." He's also got another great piece here. There's no description of it, but it's fantastic nonetheless. Kenneth Goldsmith
The Carpenters!
Kenneth Goldsmith
On Responsible AppropriationPatricia, It's all too easy to understand the fact that you felt violated by the uncredited appropriation of your poem by another person. You created it, most likely gave it away with an open heart, only later to find that you were written out of the equation. There is no justification for his actions. Copping another poet's words without it being part of a larger stated conceptual strategy is no good. And clearly, this kid's project was not an appropriation project. Ouch. So your post brings up some good thinking points. As someone who doesn't "write" any words of his own, it makes me pause to wonder why some ways of framing language is fair game for lifting and others outright theft. Primarily, I think that it has to do with intention. If this student was exploring the appropriation of other poets' work as his articulated writing practice, I |