Discussion Guide

Mapping the Pacific 

Bodies (and Bawdiness) in the July/August 2016 Poetry.

Originally Published: July 01, 2016

“Over the course of centuries,” writes Craig Santos Perez,

colonialism, militarism, capitalism, and methods of Western academia have tried to make maps of the Pacific that erase and belittle Pacific Islander connections to land and ocean. But Pacific peoples move, create, change, and love in ways that work outside and against systems bent on mapping minds and bodies along lines of Western ways of knowing and being.

The July/August 2016 Poetry features work from the Pacific Islands that maps both mind and body, in highly idiosyncratic—and significant—ways. Dan Taulapapa McMullin’s “Alaska” qualifies as a map in its own right:

is a fairy-tale queendom
  with monsters whom I don’t know
    I only know my friends the fairies
      of Alaska, the Yupik, I mean
        fairies and white mountains
          that disappear into the sky
            bonfire at Drew’s when
              Jerrod said, Dan is
                lovely, except when
                  he bitch-slapped
                    me, which I
                      didn’t, so I said,
                        With my cock!
                          and he said,
                            Well, it’s good
                              it’s small, so
                                I said, Then
                                  it was pure
                                    pleasure,
                                      yes
                                        .
                                          .
                                            .
                                              ?

This poem lives up to its title: from its broad top to its archipelago of punctuation marks, it builds an Alaska out of text. In jokingly describing the Yupik—an Eskimo people that lives in Alaska and Siberia—as fairies, McMullin toys with the tropes of exoticism: his Alaska is a queendom filled with monsters (as well as fairies). Yet his fairies and queens aren’t the kind to populate Grimm’s Fairy Tales. The poem captures not only the shape of Alaska but also the shape of flirtation: it proceeds by implication, trailing off into quiet just as the state trails off into islands (and as mountains, “fairies,” and bonfire flames “disappear into the sky”). It also, of course, provides an anatomical diagram of the body part under discussion—and in so doing, melds both poetry and geography with the human form.

Perez’s poem, “understory,” forges strikingly similar connections. “Understory” refers to an ecological phenomenon: “plant life,” he writes on his website, “growing beneath the canopy of the forest.” After his wife got pregnant, he imagined “a human understory…. Everything Brandy ate, breathed, heard, smelled, thought, felt, feared, and dreamed affected the embryo.” Like McMullin, he links the body with its surrounding world—including the most complex, and ominous, elements of that world. Everyone, he points out, dwells within an understory dominated by “colonial narratives and structures.” In crafting his own narrative and structure, Perez knits all these understories together.

Liquid links his images: the speaker’s wife, Nālani, lies on her side to breastfeed their daughter, Kaikainali‘i, while “outside, mānoa / rain falls.” The poem proceeds in couplets that match the “latched” pair of mother and daughter, and resemble—as in “Alaska”—the chain of islands it describes. And the daughter herself comes to represent tide and island both. Her breath, Perez writes,

rises and
 
falls like
king tides — 
 
her fragile
rib cage
 
appears and
disappears like
 
a coral
island crowning — 

Kaikainali‘i, who encompasses land and ocean, is also as “fragile” as both: islands disappear and reappear—or “crown,” much as a baby crowns at birth—at the mercy of ever-rising sea levels. This association grants a frightening overtone to the rain pattering outside the house: it recalls the water that threatens to overtake the land.

Bodies, too, can be overtaken, and concern over his daughter’s vulnerability—as well as islands’ vulnerability—anchors Perez’s poem. He quotes the historian Douglas Oliver:

“the rape
of oceania
 
began with
guam” — soldiers
 
invade okinawa,
hawai‘i, the
 
philippines, and
south korea —
 
#yesallwomen

Just as water threatens to invade the islands now, soldiers invaded them in the past, with disastrous consequences for Pacific Islander women. Perez’s fragmented style—(“bullets fragment / and ricochet,” he writes later)—echoes that violence.

This poem borrows not just from a history text but also from Twitter. “#yesallwomen,” an affirming hashtag used by women to express the universality of sexual oppression, here takes on an alarmingly personal valence: if all women experience sexual oppression, how can he protect his daughter? How, he writes, to “stop / kaikainali‘i’s body // from becoming / target practice”? The poem offers possible answers:

               #mmaw
#bringbackourgirls
 
nālani gathers
the clippings

The additional hashtags refer to other incidences of atrocities against women—from the hundreds of “missing and murdered aboriginal women,” in Canada, to the 276 Nigerian schoolgirls abducted by Boko Haram in 2014. Then Perez zooms back into his cozy domestic scene: his wife, who had been cutting their daughter’s nails, picks up the detritus. How to stop their daughter’s body from becoming target practice? Not just by caring for it in the most basic of ways (clipping her nails, say) but also by “gather[ing] / the clippings,” trying to clear the detritus of the world. And—since “clippings” suggests news clippings—by analyzing world events and their interconnections, by studying understories and writing them, too.